D.C. Circuit judges probe whether the NCUA is enough like the Federal Reserve to shield its leaders from presidential removal.
Credit union leagues consistently advocate keeping the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) a stable, independent federal
regulator. State leagues, such as the Nebraska Credit Union League, and national groups like America’s Credit Unions argue that only an independent agency understands the not-for-profit, cooperative structure of credit unions.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit heard oral arguments in the challenge by Todd Harper and Tanya Otsuka, NCUA board members President Donald Trump removed in April 2025. They later sued to be reinstated.
Tuesday’s arguments follow two U.S. Supreme Court rulings: Trump v. Slaughter, which held that the president can fire federal agency officials at will, and Trump v. Cook, which allowed Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook to stay in office while she contests her dismissal.
The judges questioned whether the NCUA resembles the Federal Reserve closely enough to share its protection from presidential removal.
The Department of Justice, representing the government, argued that the Fed’s independence is a narrow historical exception tied to issuing paper currency. It also noted that the NCUA statute has no explicit “for cause” protection, so its leaders can be removed at will, unlike the Fed’s.
The plaintiffs countered that the NCUA performs the same liquidity and deposit-insurance functions for credit unions that the Fed and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation perform for banks. They argued the Fed exception broadly covers regulators meant to prevent bank runs and noted that the NCUA still answers to the executive branch through the Attorney General for court enforcement.
The outcome will likely turn on whether the court sees the Fed’s removal protection as limited to currency-issuing bodies with explicit statutory shields, or as extending to functionally similar regulators. Either way, the decision could shape the independence of the NCUA and, in turn, the credit unions it oversees. The Nebraska Credit Union League will continue to monitor the case and engage as appropriate.


